music, technology & life in pasadena, california

The Complete New Yorker

A few months ago for my birthday, my wife gave me a copy of The Complete New Yorker (or TCNY, for short), the eight DVD set that holds the entire published collection of the magazine from the 1920s until (almost) the present. It’s long been my favorite magazine, full of great essays, articles, cartoons, photographs, reviews and fiction. Where else can you find the kind of in-depth writing about subjects that seem to be neglected in most of what passes for journalism today? I was excited to dive in and sample this incredible collection.

I read a lot of reviews of TCNY when it was first published. Some good, some bad. There were a lot of negative comments about the search engine. With over 4,000 issues available, you really need a good engine driving the whole thing. It takes a little time to get used to the hierarchy of the way it’s laid out, but it’s in no way difficult to use. Because the issues are presented as scanned pages, a complete text search isn’t available, but abstracts and keywords generally do a good job of getting you the information you need.

The main index and search engine are loaded onto your computer’s hard drive. From there you enter your search criteria, the results are returned, and you proceed to insert the appropriate disc that contains the items you’re interested in. Unless you’re constantly searching across years (the discs each contain a specific block of time) disc swapping is minimal and effortless. It would be nice to be able to load all eight DVDs onto your hard drive but that’s currently forbidden by the EULA, or End User Licensing Agreement. A Google search returned several how-to tutorials should you be so criminally inclined.

As soon as I installed the package and got familiar with the search engine, which allows you to not only search by keyword, but by author, department, year of publication or specific issue, or any combination thereof, I looked for the late George W.S. Trow’s 1980 essay entitled, Within The Context of No-Context. The author had died in 2006 and while reading his obituary I became aware of this ground-breaking polemic about television and mass culture. And here it was, immediately at my fingertips. It was like having a personal LexisNexis retrieval system on my laptop, albeit one that specialized in only a single magazine.

Next, I did a search for Paul Strand, the early-to-mid 20th century large-format photographer, whose work I’ve always admired. I discovered that in 1974, two years before he died, writer Calvin Tomkins wrote an extremely in-depth and lengthy profile of Strand, then living in Orgeval, France. This was a real find, based on a random search, a gem among gems. As I clicked on the writer’s name in the search engine, I could see all the profiles he had written for the magazine, and by clicking on each entry, could read an abstract of each one. Just a quick look showed me many more profiles I can’t wait to dig into, such as architect Philip Johnson, sculptor Claes Oldenburg and artist Robert Rauschenberg (from 1964, when the artist was 38 years old!)

For a long time, I had heard about writer A.J. Liebling, who wrote extensively about prizefighting, food and politics for the magazine. Here was a list of everything he had written, starting in 1933 and continuing for the next thirty years. In a random selection of a piece entitled, Letter From Gaza, Liebling writes as if the events he’s authoring are taken from today’s newspapers, until a quick look shows the date, March 16, 1957, and I am immediately sobered by the fact that as time and technology have marched on, allowing me to hold this incredible 4,000 volume collection in my hands, many things sadly remain the same.

Sure, I have a few complaints about TCNY, like the poor quality of the pages when printed on my laser printer (most likely due to the greyscale scans), the digitally distorted look of some of the photos (once again, it looks like a scanning thing), the lack of full-text search, or the use of a proprietary reader instead of the ubiquitous and much more fully-featured Adobe Reader, but the sheer joy of having at least some working version of this archive overweighs its faults…for now.

May 10, 2007 | Link to this entry


Paul Viapiano is a guitarist working in film, television and live performance based in sunny Pasadena, California.

You can email me here.

Return to the front page